Scaling Smarter with AI: How Brokers Can Win Safely

Executive Summary

The promise of AI is undeniable. For brokers, it offers the ability to scale without adding headcount, reduce errors in complex renewal work, and free up valuable time for client relationships. But AI is not magic. It is not always accurate, and it does not carry accountability for mistakes.

During our recent webinar, "Scaling Smarter with AI: How Brokers Can Win Safely," our CEO, Weston Lunsford, and CMO, Adam Smith, walked through the challenges brokers face in renewal and marketing cycles, the risks of AI adoption, and the practical guardrails every firm should put in place.

The core message: AI can be transformative, but only when adopted safely and used to empower human expertise, not replace it.

The Challenge

Broker teams are buried in tactical, repetitive work every renewal cycle. Collecting census data, chasing delayed carrier renewals, running RFPs, and formatting side-by-side spreadsheets are all essential steps, but none of them are strategic.

As Weston explained: "Every manual step is an opportunity for an error. Copy-and-paste mistakes, missed emails, formulas not updating correctly. And all of this is happening under extreme pressure while clients are demanding faster turnarounds and more transparency."

At the same time, employers are facing steep premium increases, often in the double digits. They expect faster responses, transparent comparisons, and creative plan designs. The old solution of throwing more people at the problem does not scale, and it burns teams out.

3 Ways AI Helps Brokers Win

1. Scale Without Headcount

AI can process thousands of quotes and plan documents in seconds. Tasks that used to take hours now happen in minutes, enabling firms to serve more clients without adding staff.

2. Reduce Risk and Improve Accuracy

As Weston noted, "AI doesn't get tired at 11:30 at night. It normalizes data, checks for consistency, and flags variances so you can have confidence that nothing was missed."

3. Free Up Time for Strategy and Relationships

Technology should give brokers time back for what clients actually value: negotiations, creative plan design, and stronger relationships. Adam put it simply: "Clients don't stay with you because you upload quotes quickly. They stay because you bring insight, trust, and creativity."

The Hidden Risks of AI

AI's benefits are real, but so are its risks.

• Data Privacy: Public tools like ChatGPT or Gemini are not HIPAA-compliant. Sensitive census or renewal data cannot legally be uploaded.
  
• Compliance Gaps: Without SOC 2 or HIPAA safeguards, firms expose themselves to regulatory risk.
  
• Accuracy Without Accountability: Models make mistakes. As Adam shared in a story about a home project, AI confidently gave him the wrong answer until he caught the error himself. "It saved me time, but if I trusted it blindly, I would have had a wall I didn't want."

The lesson: AI is fast, but it must be thoroughly checked. Without human oversight, speed can amplify mistakes.

Choosing AI Safely: 3 Types of Tools

• Public AI: Free or low-cost but unsafe for client data. Best for brainstorming only.
  
• Self-Hosted AI: Maximum control, but requires millions of dollars and dedicated teams. Not realistic for most brokerages.
  
• Industry-Specific AI Providers: Purpose-built solutions with built-in safeguards and compliance. These strike a balance between security and practicality.

The Do's and Don'ts of AI Adoption

Do's:

• Use private, secure ecosystems.
• Protect client and employee data.
• Validate performance with your documents.
• Ensure transparency in how data is handled.
• Use AI to support human judgment, not replace it.

Don'ts:

• Put sensitive data into public AI tools.
• Take vendor claims at face value.
• Assume accuracy without context.
• Don't trust "100% accuracy" claims.
• Don't skip QA/QC review just because AI is fast.

Questions to Ask AI Vendors

1. How do you handle sensitive data?
   
2. Are you HIPAA compliant and SOC 2 certified?
   
3. What quality assurance and control processes are in place?
   
4. Can you prove accuracy using my own documents?

If a vendor stumbles on these questions, move on.

Product Spotlights: AI in Action
During the webinar, we shared real-world examples of how PlansightAI is already transforming brokerage operations. These product spotlights highlight the day-to-day impact AI can have.

SmartSheetingAI™

Spreadsheets have long been a bottleneck in the renewal cycle. Service teams spend hours cutting, pasting, and reformatting carrier proposals into side-by-side comparisons. With SmartSheetingAI, brokers can upload a proposal in PDF, Excel, or CSV, and the system automatically normalizes the data, highlights deviations, and generates a clean, usable comparison.

One midsize brokerage reported that their team spent 8–10 hours on each large renewal. With SmartSheetingAI, they reduced that time to under 30 minutes. As Weston emphasized, "That is not just efficiency. That is literally an entire day freed up for strategy and client conversations."

Renewal Automation and QA/QC

Every manual step in the renewal process presents an opportunity for an error. Renewal Automation mitigates these risks by automating data intake and reconciliation, while also embedding quality control checks. AI validates carrier quotes against expected formats, flags variances, and ensures consistency.

Adam highlighted the benefit this way: "AI doesn't get tired at 11:30 at night. It doesn't transpose numbers. It flags what needs attention so your team can focus on strategy instead of double-checking formulas."

PlansightAI: Purpose-Built for Brokers

Unlike public AI tools that are fast but unsafe, or self-hosted AI that is unrealistic for most firms, PlansightAI was designed specifically for insurance brokers. It integrates automation into workflows like SmartSheeting, renewal automation, and side-by-side comparisons while meeting HIPAA and SOC 2 compliance.

Weston summed it up: "At the end of the day, AI doesn't replace people. It makes them more valuable. That is why we built PlansightAI to protect time, reduce liability, and elevate client relationships."

Why PlansightAI

At Plansight, we built PlansightAI specifically for brokers. It is not a generic tool. It was designed to handle complex insurance documents with embedded QA/QC, HIPAA safeguards, and SOC 2 certification.

Key Takeaways

• AI is no longer optional for brokers who want to compete in the future.
• Public tools should never be used for sensitive data.
• Industry-specific solutions provide the best balance of safety and performance.
• Human review and oversight are always required.

Ready to See PlansightAI in Action?

PlansightAI gives brokers the ability to scale smarter and safer. Schedule a discovery call today to see how your team can win with AI.

‍